Texas Democrats are moving to limit the use of automated license plate readers after an investigation revealed that millions of dollars collected from motorists were used to install thousands of Flock surveillance cameras across the state.
Several lawmakers have filed legislation ahead of the 2027 legislative session aimed at restricting or banning the cameras, which have drawn growing criticism over privacy concerns, government surveillance and the use of taxpayer-funded grants.
State Sen. Carol Alvarado, D-Houston, is leading one of those efforts with legislation that would prohibit the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority from awarding grants for roadside automated license plate readers.
The proposal follows revelations that the authority spent more than $30 million helping law enforcement agencies install at least 3,200 Flock cameras.
The money came from a funding program established through legislation Alvarado sponsored in 2023. That measure added a $1 annual fee to Texas auto insurance policies to support efforts to combat catalytic converter theft.
The legislation received unanimous approval in both chambers, but Alvarado later expressed surprise that the funding had been used to build an extensive roadside surveillance network.
Democratic Sens. Roland Gutierrez, José Menéndez and Taylor Rehmet have joined Alvarado as co-authors of the new proposal.
The spending extended beyond grants to local police departments. The authority also approved a $15.9 million contract to help the Texas Department of Public Safety install more than 1,200 cameras.
Ultimately, 940 Flock cameras were installed through that funding arrangement.
By June, thousands of law enforcement agencies nationwide were accessing the network at an average rate of once every four seconds.
Unlike traditional traffic cameras, Flock devices collect detailed information about passing vehicles, including license plates, makes, models, colors and distinguishing features such as dents or bumper stickers.
The company's technology allows participating agencies to search information collected by other departments, creating an interconnected surveillance system that stretches across jurisdictions.
An estimated 13,000 Flock cameras were operating in Texas in late August. That number has since declined as local governments reconsider their contracts amid growing public opposition.
Gov. Greg Abbott also ordered a freeze on state funding for the cameras after questions emerged about how the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority had distributed its grants.
The funding suspension prompted several municipalities to terminate their agreements with Flock Safety.
The company offered some cities a 90-day break from payments in hopes that state funding would resume after the November election.
However, the election of Democratic Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa has raised additional questions about the future of the program.
Hinojosa campaigned against the cameras and criticized the authority for expanding the surveillance network without specific legislative authorization. She has also called for removing the cameras and returning public money spent on the installations.
Other lawmakers are pursuing different approaches to the technology.
State Rep. John Bucy, D-Austin, has introduced legislation that would prohibit public agencies from using automated license plate readers altogether.
His proposal would extend beyond Flock cameras to similar technology manufactured by companies such as Axon and Vigilant.
Meanwhile, state Rep. Mary González, D-Clint, has filed legislation requiring law enforcement officers to obtain a warrant before searching license plate reader databases.
Her proposal would also clarify which records generated by the systems must be available to the public, an issue that has become increasingly contentious as departments restrict access to camera search logs.
Republican state Rep. Brian Harrison of Midlothian has introduced another proposal requiring warrants and limiting camera use to investigations involving violent crimes.
Harrison previously introduced similar legislation during the last two legislative sessions.
The competing proposals set up a significant debate over public safety, privacy protections and government oversight when lawmakers convene in 2027.
