Reinaldo Dennes, 70, was pronounced dead at 7:08 p.m. Thursday, November 19, at the Huntsville Unit following a 63-minute procedure during which prison officials struggled to establish intravenous lines.

Texas Department of Criminal Justice spokesperson Amanda Hernandez told the Associated Press that execution personnel ultimately inserted IV lines into Dennes’ left foot and the left side of his neck after several unsuccessful attempts.

“The pain!” Dennes exclaimed shortly after the procedure began, according to Associated Press correspondent Michael Graczyk, who has witnessed nearly 500 Texas executions.

Graczyk reported that Dennes repeatedly moaned for nearly three minutes and complained of pain in his right leg.

Hernandez maintained that personnel followed state procedures but questioned Dennes’ complaints, noting that he reported pain before the drugs began flowing and in areas where no IV lines were inserted.

What caused his apparent suffering remains unclear.

Three Decades on Death Row

Dennes was sentenced to death for the January 24, 1996, robbery and murder of Houston diamond dealer Janos Szucs. Security guard David Copeland was also injured during the attack and died before Dennes’ execution.

The U.S. Supreme Court denied Dennes’ request for a stay Thursday, clearing the way for Texas to carry out the sentence nearly 31 years after the murder.

However, that decision did not address the complications that subsequently occurred inside the execution chamber.

A Failed Execution in Tennessee

The Texas execution comes less than two months after Tennessee attempted unsuccessfully to execute Christa Gail Pike, who was convicted of murdering 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer in 1995.

Pike survived two doses of pentobarbital during her September 30 execution attempt. Her attorneys contend that malfunctioning IV lines may have allowed the drugs to enter surrounding tissue rather than circulate properly through her bloodstream.

Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee suspended the state's remaining 2026 executions and called for an independent review.

No new execution date has been announced, and litigation surrounding Pike’s treatment and confinement continues.

Are There More Reliable Alternatives?

A historical study by Amherst College professor Austin Sarat examined 8,776 American executions between 1890 and 2010 and classified 276 as botched.

Lethal injection had the highest reported failure rate among the methods examined, at approximately 7.2 percent, compared with 3.12 percent for hanging.

The study recorded no botched executions among 34 firing squad executions, although some historical accounts challenge that finding.

More recently, an autopsy following South Carolina’s April 2025 execution of Mikal Mahdi found that only two of three bullets struck him and neither hit his heart, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Those statistics do not necessarily measure suffering, and no execution method guarantees a painless death.

Texas adopted lethal injection in 1977 and became the first state to use it in 1982 with the execution of Charles Brooks Jr. The method was regarded as a less visibly violent alternative to traditional execution practices.

Changing execution methods in Texas would require legislative action because state law specifically mandates lethal injection.

When Does an Execution Become Cruel and Unusual?

The Eighth Amendment prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, but complications during an execution do not automatically establish a constitutional violation.

The Supreme Court has generally required prisoners challenging execution methods to demonstrate a substantial risk of severe pain and identify a feasible alternative that significantly reduces that risk.

No court has determined that Dennes’ execution violated his constitutional rights.

Nevertheless, Texas lawmakers have legitimate reasons to examine execution procedures, personnel training and the circumstances surrounding Thursday’s execution.

Regardless of where Texans stand on capital punishment, the state has a responsibility to explain what happens behind the execution chamber’s walls, particularly when witnesses report complications and apparent suffering.