The Amarillo City Council went into Monday morning’s special meeting expecting to revisit tax-rate calculations. What council members got instead was a substantially different picture of the city’s finances — and a new debate over what to do with money that, until recently, officials did not realize was available.

The special meeting was scheduled after errors were discovered in numbers used to calculate Amarillo’s 2026 property tax rates, forcing the city to recalculate ahead of the Sept. 30 tax-rate adoption deadline.

The corrections did not change the no-new-revenue rate, which remains $0.42170 per $100 of taxable valuation. They did, however, increase the voter-approved rate — the highest rate the city can adopt without taking it to voters — by $0.00508 to $0.45252.

More importantly for taxpayers and the council, correcting the numbers revealed millions of dollars in additional capacity within the city budget.

The errors involved several different parts of the tax-rate calculation.

Tax rates originally presented to the council had used debt collection numbers exceeding $2 million. Another $1.1 million in debt associated with fleet purchases had been included in the general revenue fund, which includes property tax revenue, even though that debt is actually paid through fees.

Then there was the issue involving Amarillo’s tax increment reinvestment zones, commonly known as TIRZ.

Additional taxable value generated within the zones had essentially been deducted from city revenue twice. The impact for the upcoming budget is approximately $1.2 million.

The double deduction has been part of the calculation for years, although it remains unclear how many. Amarillo’s first TIRZ, covering the downtown area, was established in 2006, but the information presented Monday did not establish that the error dates back that far.

Mayor Cole Stanley explained how the problem occurred.

“The staff had calculated the additional values that come up through TIRZ; so, in a TIRZ, you encapsulate, or you hold the existing values,” Stanley said. “What’s built in that zone then gets taxed and gets held in that zone. So, they were essentially taking that value and deducting it from our revenues twice.”

According to the explanation provided Monday, the TIRZ calculation resulted in money accumulating in debt reserves. The excess debt reserve can now be used to pay down debt and lower the tax rate.

There is an important point in how the mistakes were discovered. The recalculation followed questions from the City Council, particularly Stanley, about exactly how much revenue the different proposed tax rates would generate.

City Manager Grayson Path has previously said this is the first year in recent memory that city staff has been asked to consider a no-new-revenue rate.

That additional scrutiny changed the numbers the council had in front of it.

According to the revised calculations, the no-new-revenue rate would produce around $4.3 million more than originally anticipated, including just over $843,000 in new revenue not captured last year.

At the same time, city staff is now projecting approximately $800,000 more in sales tax revenue than previously presented after collections for the current fiscal year were completed.

Taken together, the new numbers substantially change the budget discussion.

Based on the figures presented Monday, Amarillo could adopt the no-new-revenue property tax rate and still fund raises for civilian and sworn city employees, provide more than $2 million for recurring departmental requests and make nearly $14 million in one-time purchases or projects. After doing all of that, roughly $880,000 would remain available.

The budget requests council members have been reviewing this tax season can be paid for at the no-new-revenue rate, with almost $80,000 still available to allocate from that portion of the budget.

If the council ultimately chooses the voter-approved rate, it could fund those priorities and have almost $6 million left to allocate.

That creates an unusual budget debate.

Rather than simply determining whether a higher tax rate is required to pay for the requests already under consideration, council members now have to decide how much revenue the city should collect and what should be done with the additional financial capacity revealed by the recalculations.

There are several competing priorities.

Employee compensation remains a significant concern for some council members. Place Three Councilmember David Prescott wants the city to consider a strong pay increase.

Stanley is optimistic the upcoming fiscal year could also bring increased permit and fee revenue. He has expressed interest in looking at larger raises, including step-pay incentives requested by the Amarillo Police Department, while also setting aside money to assist Amarillo senior citizens. Place Two Councilmember Don Tipps agreed.

Place One Councilmember Tim Reid approached the additional money more conservatively. He wants the city to examine whether using some of it to retire debt could provide savings for taxpayers.

Reid also identified needs that could justify additional spending.

“I agree with putting some money into the senior citizens. I know that we need a fire training facility, a new facility,” Reid said. “That would be something that serves the public, and I think if we’re going to spend some money, that’s probably where I would like to see it.”

There may also be more questions to answer about Amarillo’s debt.

Stanley asked city staff Monday to review budgeted debt in the water and sewer fund, which represents about half of Amarillo’s approximately $566.8 million in total debt. Staff agreed to double-check those figures and return with more information at the Sept. 22 meeting.

Given the corrections already made to the tax calculations, that additional review could become an important part of the council’s final budget decisions.

The calculation problems also raised questions about where the incorrect information originated.

Potter County Tax Assessor-Collector Thomas Warren III and Randall County Tax Assessor-Collector Christina McMurray attended Monday’s meeting. Warren explained that his office’s software generates a report that is then sent to McMurray’s office.

“What we kind of have discovered was the number that was in there incorrectly: it looks like, based on our internal research, it looks like it was provided by City staff,” Warren said.

Warren’s office has since developed an internal form to send to taxing entities to provide another check that the numbers are correct moving forward.

Tipps asked perhaps the most consequential question of the meeting: What would have happened if the mistakes had not been discovered?

“We would have kept growing our excess debt reserves, and it would have ultimately kept ballooning until we caught it. And with that fleet as well, we would have ultimately caught that,” Deputy City Manager Andrew Freeman said.

The answer illustrates why the council’s scrutiny of the calculations matters. According to the information presented Monday, the errors were affecting how much money was being placed into debt reserves and the financial information council members were using as they considered the tax rate.

The council’s disagreement Monday ultimately centered on how much flexibility it should preserve before adopting the final rate.

Council members first had to establish a not-to-exceed rate. They can ultimately adopt a rate below that ceiling, but they cannot later raise it above the ceiling.

Place Four Councilmember Les Simpson, who has advocated for property tax relief during this budget season, moved to set the ceiling at the no-new-revenue rate of $0.42170.

Nobody seconded the motion, so it failed.

Reid said he did not believe that approach was prudent and proposed setting the not-to-exceed rate at $0.4307, the same as the 2025 tax rate. That rate would generate around $1.5 million more in property tax revenue than originally budgeted.

What followed illustrated just how unsettled the council remains over the final number.

Three motions failed.

Prescott and Tipps voted to set the ceiling at the voter-approved tax rate. Reid and Stanley then voted to set it at the 2025 tax rate. Tipps and Prescott subsequently supported setting the ceiling just below the voter-approved rate.

“It makes no sense not to just put a ceiling that is just arbitrary to just move forward,” Tipps said.

Eventually, Stanley, Reid and Tipps voted to establish the 2025 tax rate as the not-to-exceed rate.

Simpson voted against every motion.

“I don’t want property owners to have to pay more tax next year, and we already figured out that it could be done … I was not going to approve a rate that would exceed that rate,” Simpson said after the meeting.

Stanley also said he would not support setting the ceiling higher than a tax rate he would actually be willing to vote for.

One distinction will be important as the debate continues: the tax rate and an individual property owner’s tax bill are not the same thing.

The amount of tax levied varies based on taxable property values. If a property’s taxable value increases, its owner could pay more in city property taxes even if the City Council adopts a lower tax rate.

That makes the debate over the no-new-revenue rate more complicated than simply describing it as a tax increase or tax cut.

What Monday’s meeting did establish is that the council now has more financial flexibility than members believed they had when the budget process began.

The city can apparently fund the budget requests council members have been reviewing at the no-new-revenue rate. Council members could also choose a higher rate and direct additional revenue toward employee compensation, departmental needs, senior citizens, capital projects or other priorities. Another option raised Monday is using more money to reduce debt.

Those are policy choices rather than accounting questions, and council members clearly have different ideas about which direction Amarillo should take.

But the accounting questions matter because the answers determine the choices available to them.

The discovery of incorrect debt numbers and a years-long double deduction involving TIRZ revenue demonstrates the importance of understanding not simply what Amarillo’s tax rate is, but how that rate was calculated and how much revenue it will actually generate.

For taxpayers, that may be the biggest takeaway from Monday’s meeting.

The council began asking more detailed questions about the revenue behind the proposed rates, and the answers changed the financial picture considerably. Now that council members have those corrected numbers, the debate can move to where it belongs: how much money Amarillo needs to collect and what taxpayers should receive in return.

The public will have its next opportunity to weigh in when the council holds a budget hearing during its regular meeting on Sept. 22. City staff is also expected to return with additional information about water and sewer debt.

Before then, the council is scheduled to meet in closed executive session Wednesday at 11 a.m. to discuss personnel matters related to the city manager.

With the Sept. 30 tax-rate deadline approaching, the council still has decisions to make. The difference now is that members should be making those decisions with a more accurate understanding of the money actually available.