Last week, the Texas Commission on Jail Standards (TCJS) issued a failing grade to the Potter County Detention Center—a consequence that, according to Sheriff Brian Thomas, didn’t come as a surprise. “Didn’t even come close,” Thomas told Potter County Commissioners in a Tuesday meeting. His blunt assessment reflects a growing crisis that’s been simmering for years: chronic overcrowding, inadequate resources, rising crime, and a fractured political process that is now colliding with state oversight.
While the official inspection report hasn’t been released to the public yet, the reasons behind the failure are already clear. The jail was over its legal capacity for 101 days—sometimes by just one person, sometimes by as many as sixteen. But in the eyes of state regulators, even one person without a bed is one too many. That alone was enough to put the facility out of compliance.
Now, the clock is ticking. Potter County has 30 days to create an action plan, submit daily compliance reports, and fix the problem. If they fail again, the issue escalates—to the Texas Attorney General’s office, and possibly to a shutdown or reduction in jail capacity.
And for anyone who thinks this is just bureaucratic red tape, consider Liberty County. Their jail was shut down last month by TCJS after repeated violations, including riots, fires, and years of overcrowding. Potter County isn’t immune. It's on the same path unless real, common-sense solutions are implemented—and fast.
Overcrowding: The Core Problem No One Has Solved
The Potter County Detention Center isn’t overflowing for no reason. It’s a jail situated in a high-crime area with complex public needs. Sheriff Thomas outlined the many contributing factors: two major highways (I-40 and U.S. 287), both hospitals, all local homeless shelters, the Pavilion psychiatric facility, and high levels of theft—often from out-of-county perpetrators drawn in by big-box retailers.
It’s a unique geography that serves as a magnet for crime, both petty and violent. And while other counties may be able to house low-risk detainees for a fee, they’re not lining up to take violent offenders, which make up a large portion of Potter County’s inmate population.
The cost of outsourcing inmates is astronomical. The county has already spent more than half a million dollars to house inmates elsewhere—but that doesn’t include the cost of transport, fuel, or employee overtime. As Thomas put it, “It’s just a big old ugly circle.”
A Band-Aid or a Real Plan?
The solution, at least on the surface, appears to be expanding the jail. But how big should it be? In December, a now-disbanded citizen committee recommended adding 288 new beds. The projected cost? $20 million, rising 10% per year if delayed. Others on the Commissioners Court, like Commissioner John Coffee, have asked for more data before making that kind of financial leap.
Coffee is pushing for an independent consultant to assess long-term needs before signing off on expansion. His logic? If you're going to spend tens of millions in taxpayer dollars, you better be sure it's the right move.
He has a point. In 2019, a facilities needs assessment found Potter County needed 672 beds. By 2024, that number had dropped to 624, raising questions about the accuracy of the projections or what’s changed. Without a clear strategic plan, building more beds could mean throwing good money after bad—especially if the jail is full again the day it reopens.
The Fight Over Process—and Power
Behind the policy debate is a growing political rift between Sheriff Thomas and Commissioner Coffee. At the heart of it is a directive from the Sheriff, instructing his employees not to communicate with Commissioner Coffee unless routed through the Sheriff’s chain of command. Noncompliance could mean termination. Critics say this is a clear overreach that risks employee rights and limits transparency.
Coffee called it “disappointing” and said it puts county employees in a “legally awkward” position. He emphasized his desire for transparency and fiscal responsibility, saying the real issue is jail overcrowding, not politics.
In the courtroom, Potter County Attorney Scott Brumley confirmed the Sheriff has the legal right to issue such a directive. But even Brumley admitted the policy “potentially creates First Amendment risks.” County Judge Nancy Tanner was more blunt: “I wouldn’t do it.”
Sheriff Thomas later clarified he wasn’t trying to muzzle anyone—only control how official communications are routed within his department. But in the context of a major compliance failure and an ongoing crisis, the directive feels like a distraction the county can’t afford.
The Bigger Picture: A System Near Collapse
Potter County is not alone. Across Texas, jails are reaching or exceeding capacity. Harris County has 2,400 inmates farmed out across four states, and pending legislation could bring all of them back to Texas—shrinking already limited bed availability for counties like Potter.
Meanwhile, jail expansion is not a quick fix. Even a 144-bed expansion could take three years to complete. By then, population increases could negate the added capacity, leaving the county right back where it started.
And that’s if the expansion even happens. After Tuesday’s meeting, the Commissioners Court took no action on hiring the architect or expanding the scope of the jail’s design. Commissioner Coffee pushed again for a consultant. Mike Head, Director of Facilities Maintenance, countered that a consultant would cost five times more and take years to produce results the architect could deliver in months.
The decision is now at a crossroads. Do county leaders move forward with urgent expansion to avoid more state penalties, or take a step back for a broader plan that could take years—but might be smarter long-term?
What Now?
The truth is, there are no easy answers. But what’s clear is this: jail overcrowding isn’t a problem that will solve itself. It requires cooperation, not conflict. Planning, not politics.
Sheriff Thomas is right to say, “We’ve had our try—now it’s time to act.” But if the county acts without the right data, it risks wasting millions in taxpayer dollars on a project that may be outdated the day it opens.
Commissioner Coffee is also right. Transparency, strategy, and community input are critical when the stakes are this high.
Potter County doesn’t just need more jail beds. It needs leadership that puts facts over ego, collaboration over control, and long-term vision over quick fixes.
.png)
