The third edition of the College Football Playoff Rankings was released Tuesday night with Georgia, Alabama, Oregon and Ohio State remaining as the top four teams for the second straight week. Not only that, the first seven teams in the top 25 were unchanged as all won games in a week that only saw one significant upset.

That came as Baylor knocked off previously unbeaten and eighth-ranked Oklahoma, a result that saw the Sooners fall five spots to No. 13, while the Bears moved up to two spots to No. 11. The CFP Selection Committee clearly focused on the head-to-head result above overall record given Baylor has one more loss than Oklahoma. Neither is the top-ranked Big 12 team, though, as Oklahoma State holds that distinction at No. 9 ahead of a Bedlam meeting with OU in two weeks.

Cincinnati, at 10-0 with two Power Five wins, held at No. 5 after a clean win over South Florida. The Bearcats remain the highest-ranked Group of Five program in this history of the CFP Rankings, but as of right now, that's only good enough for a New Year's Six bid given they are outside the top four. However, Cincinnati did receive some good news from the committee due to it finally ranking Houston. 

In the history of the CFP, no team ranked outside the top seven at this late point in the season has moved into the four-team field after the conference championship games. The No. 7 team has advanced to the top four twice: Oklahoma in 2017, Georgia in 2019.

There have been plenty of head scratching moments from the playoff committee on a weekly basis so I thought it would be fun to share my five thoughts on this week’s playoff rankings.


It’s not news anymore at this point because each and every year it feels like everyone on the playoff committee could care less about the Big 12 Conference. Last Week, Oklahoma was undefeated with an 9-0 record yet there were five teams with a loss ranked ahead of them. The committee doesn’t have to worry about the Sooners anymore because they are now ranked thirteenth after falling to a top fifteen Baylor squad.

Then we have the highest ranked Big 12 team in Oklahoma State checking in at number nine. The Cowboys are 9-1 and have been playing great football over the last few weeks yet it seems like the committee still views them as a pretender instead of a contender. They are behind THREE Big Ten east teams who all have one loss.

Speaking of the Big Ten east, why are there three Big Ten teams from the same division ranked in the top seven? That makes zero sense and of course it is going to be used to prop up Michigan, Michigan State and Ohio State. Out of all these three teams, who have they beaten? Ohio State doesn’t have a win over any team currently ranked in the top 25. Michigan State beat Michigan (yet are still somehow ranked behind them) and Michigan’s best win was against a three loss Wisconsin team. Give me break.


Something that nobody is talking about is the fact that Oregon lost to a team with a current record of 3-7. If not for their week two win against Ohio State, this team wouldn’t even sniff the top four but because the committee feels the need to prop up the Big Ten, they have to be ranked ahead of the Buckeyes moving forward. The Ducks got a get out of jail free card with their early season win and with a weak Pac-12 schedule, they have the easiest path to make the playoff out of anyone else in the entire country.

Despite being ranked number five last week, the Bearcats didn’t have a lot of juice left in their schedule to get the attention of the playoff committee. Now with Houston finally cracking the top 25, could that be enough to boost Cincinnati into the top four if Alabama falls to Georgia in the SEC title game? I think it should. Of course, Houston needs to beat Memphis and UConn to finish out the year but if they do that and meet Cincinnati in the AAC title game, that could be the final piece to get the Bearcats in. But who knows considering how little the committee thinks of group of five teams.


It’s no secret that Joey Galloway is the worst college football analyst that ESPN has. The stuff that comes out of his mouth on a weekly basis is jaw dropping at times because most of what he spews is complete garbage. Take a listen to him making a case for Alabama to stay at number two even if they lose to Georgia in the SEC title game. Keep in mind, Alabama already has one loss so another one would make them a two-loss team who didn’t even win their conference.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post